Emergency physician Dr. Rebekah Mannix relays the story of her teenage goddaughter who developed vomiting and eventually a dire diagnosis of metastatic cancer in JAMA’s “And Still We Believed.”
Mannix finds herself researching experimental treatments, hoping for a “miracle,” but unable to find any in the medical world: “We did not comprehend that someone so healthy and vibrant…could succumb.” Even after the patient was transferred to comfort measures only, Mannix admits she “still wasn’t ‘there’ yet.” “Even as I knew she would die, I believed she wouldn’t.”
Mannix speaks to the idea that even as physicians, as scientists, we “know better” but still our humanity takes precedence over logic and understanding. There is a lesson here for medical providers. Patients may comprehend what we tell them, but they might not always believe it: “Even as they sit holding the hand of a loved one on a morphine drip–whose organs have shut down, whose words have ceased–they still may not believe death will come.”
Writing Prompt: Have you ever experienced a dire diagnosis for your yourself or a loved one and not believed it? If you’re a physician, how can we best navigate supporting a patient or their family when, despite clear evidence to the contrary, they “still believe.” Write for 10 minutes.