Narrative Medicine

Narrative Medicine Monday: What I Learned Photographing Death

No Comments

Caroline Catlin shares her riveting story of how photographing those with terminal illness gave her perspective about her own cancer diagnosis in the New York Times’ “What I Learned Photographing Death.”

Catlin volunteers with Soulumination, a nonprofit organization that documents moments between critically ill individuals and their families, including the end of a child’s life. As I also live in Washington State, I had heard of this remarkable organization and the unique and thoughtful service they provide. Catlin’s piece, though, also reveals the perspective of these volunteer photographers. As Catlin describes, her role is to enter a room “ready to capture the way that love honors the dying. Witnessing these small moments helps me come to terms with my own mortality.” Her experience echoes that of many who work in the medical field. She too is a kind of caregiver for these families, wielding a camera rather than a stethoscope.

This young writer and photographer describes how in October she herself became a patient, eventually being diagnosed with malignant brain cancer. Catlin highlights how, since her diagnosis, she’s bonded with the people she’s photographing in a new way, including a teenager who shared mutual baldness: “The fact that I am sick and young has helped me form new connections with the people I am photographing.”

Catlin describes photographing the birth and death of a baby who was born with a condition that wasn’t survivable. She writes with heartbreaking clarity how “[h]e was perfect, but he did not cry,” how she captured “[h]is arm…gentle across his mother’s face — I clicked the shutter to save this gesture.”

Catlin is clear on her purpose in doing this difficult work: “When I am in those rooms, I am present with the sole goal of finding the moments within grief that feel the most gentle and human.” She also has discovered moments that speak to her own confrontation with mortality, such as when a child cries over the loss of his sister, then goes on to play near her body. She recognizes the resilience that exists in this world, that her friends and family “will also continue to live on if I die too soon.”

In the end, Catlin’s revelation is that “grief is centered not in pain but in love.” This is the lesson that she shares with us, the encouragement that “in our most horrific of moments we are met with small pricks of bright light, piercing and strong.”

Writing Prompt: In this piece, Catlin expresses how her work with Soulumination gave insight into her own experience with cancer and facing mortality. If you’re a medical provider, what has your work revealed to you about your own mortality? Alternatively, think about a time you stepped into another person’s story, during a particularly challenging time, either as a friend or family member or stranger. What did you learn from walking alongside that person, listening or observing? Write for 10 minutes.

Continue Reading

Narrative Medicine

Narrative Medicine Monday: How Virginia Woolf Taught Me to Mourn

No Comments

Katharine Smyth explains “How Virginia Woolf Taught Me to Mourn” in her recent essay on Literary Hub. Smyth outlines how Woolf described the mourning period surrounding her mother’s death, and how that “spring of 1895 in London… may as well have been the winter of 2007 in Boston” when she was grieving her own father.

Smyth and her mother illustrate how people can react to grief differently. Her mother “saw the ringing doorbell as an interruption,” while Smyth “liked hearing from the outside world: grief is rapacious, and cards and flowers functioned as its fuel. As long as they continued to proliferate, the experience of loss was active, almost diverting. It was only when their numbers dwindled, then ceased altogether, that a kind of dullish hunger set in.” I think the same can be said of those who experience trauma. Often, others surround you during and immediately after the event, but as time progresses and active support dwindles, a loneliness takes its place.

One of Smyth’s friends “invited me to her parents’ apartment for a kind of mini sitting shiva. For several hours she and her mother listened as I talked about my father’s life; I loved that neither was cowed by death’s awkwardness.” This gift to Smyth seemed an unexpected balm. Do you think most of us succumb to death’s awkwardness? Why do you think this is a cultural norm?

Smyth notes that when the distractions end, “Above all, I disliked the passing of time, disliked the thought that every minute carried me further from my father.” She can relate to Woolf’s surreal experience in the wake of a parent’s death: “The tragedy of her mother’s death, she said, ‘was not that it made one, now and then and very intensely, unhappy. It was that it made her unreal; and us solemn, and self-conscious. We were made to act parts that we did not feel; to fumble for words that we did not know. . . . It made one hypocritical and immeshed in the conventions of sorrow.'”

Smyth identifies with Lily in Woolf’s To the Lighthouse: “her frustrations are those of the grown writer who must confront grief’s fogginess, its unreliability. ‘Why repeat this over and over again?’ she thinks angrily of her attempts to register the fact of Mrs. Ramsay’s passing.” Smyth, too, finds herself repeating, “My father is dead, I continued to say, my father is dead.”

In To the Lighthouse, Smyth discovers that Woolf conveys “her understanding that we all need some structure by which to contain and grapple with our dead.”

Writing Prompt: Although not religious, Smyth finds the act of sitting shiva cathartic, finds herself “longing for ritual, for structure, for some organizing principle by which to counter the awful shapelessness of loss.” Think of your own experience of grief or loss. Can you relate to the healing benefits of structure? Write for 10 minutes.

Continue Reading

Narrative Medicine

Narrative Medicine Monday: Heroin/e

No Comments

In Cheryl Strayed’s essay “Heroin/e” she writes about our ways of facing death, dying, grief and the will to live. Strayed loses her mother to cancer and suffers her own descent into addiction. Strayed’s love for her mother is evident and the loss she feels is acute. When her mother first learns of her diagnosis, Strayed recounts them silently entering the restroom, “Each of us locked in separate stalls, weeping. We didn’t say a word.” Strayed describes the numbing of pain and the warping of time for each of them: “The days of my mother’s death, the morphine days, and those that followed, the heroin days, lasted only weeks, months–but each day was an eternity, one stacked up on the other, a cold clarity inside of a deep haze.”

Writing Prompt: What does it feel like, in a physical sense, to suffer from addiction? From grief? Do you think addiction and grief are linked? Why or why not? Think of your own experience or a time you’ve witnessed this in a patient. Write for 10 minutes.

Continue Reading