I featured one of Dr. Thomas Gibbs’ other essays on my very first Narrative Medicine Monday post in 2016. Today’s piece, found in the excellent flash essay journal Brevity, highlights another experience altogether. Dr. Gibbs is an obstetrician and therefore encounters dramatic medical emergencies that can put two lives at risk simultaneously. This was the case in “The Train,” when Gibbs is paged in the early morning hours about a bleeding pregnant patient who works in his office. Gibbs tells her husband to drive the patient himself to the hospital as he knows the urgency of the situation and that the local EMTs would take longer to get her there. He treats the patient as she arrives and disaster is averted. When he goes to inform the patient’s husband in the waiting room, he finds the husband shaken. In just getting to the hospital, all of them were in danger.

This piece made me think of all the advice we give patients, all the instructions we get from well-meaning physicians. Sometimes this advice has unintended consequences, either because patients misinterpret what was said or the instructions weren’t communicated effectively or because of events entirely out of anyone’s control. When you read the final lines of this essay, what were your first thoughts about the situation?

Writing Prompt: Have you given or gotten advice from a physician that, when followed, caused unforeseen consequences? Consider what happened or imagine what could have happened. As a physician, how did this change your medical practice or, as a patient, your relationship with that physician? Write for 10 minutes.